Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Guest Rwar007
Posted

Yeah I was very upset last year when they filled only half the quotas. I hope this year the at least fill them all as the community constantly moans about need for bodies. I just tried to improve my package by doing the PME for Officers via Naval War College and the Unit OIC/NOSC CO course developed by CNRFC. Also I don’t particularly get a good feeling with only two community members on the board....one is a recorder so needless to say I feel my chances are still slim.

  • Replies 558
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Guest McMustang6330
Posted
6 minutes ago, Sbreakall said:

My first time applying for reserve 649X. I noticed last 4 years they didn't fill quotas. In that situation, do you get any feedback from anyone on why they'd rather have no one than the applicants? I'm half expecting the same result for me this year. I also applied for 626X, also unfilled quota 4 years in a row. 

No one from the board will give you direct feedback on why you weren't selected.  It can be somewhat frustrating to have to read between the lines, but it means that they didn't feel that enough candidates met the "best and fully qualified" checks according to discrete requirements, and those outlined in the precepts.  If you don't get selected, review those two documents and carefully compare them to your package, and you should see what you need to work on.  This is assuming you don't have a mentor to discuss this with, and receive some guidance and direction.

Guest Sbreakall
Posted
Just now, McMustang6330 said:

No one from the board will give you direct feedback on why you weren't selected.  In can be somewhat frustrating to have to read between the lines, but it means that they didn't feel that enough candidates met the "best and fully qualified" checks according to discrete requirements, and those outlined in the precepts.  If you don't get selected, review those two documents and carefully compare them to your package, and you should see what you need to work on.  This is assuming you don't have a mentor to discuss this with, and receive some guidance and direction.

It's just so different on the reserve side because the precepts mention civilian experience counting, but no guideline on what and how that experience counts. For example, 649X says that civilian law enforcement experience can be used to supplement navy experience, particularly at the sergeant level. There's no way for the board to know the difference between someone who works as a sergeant at a small PD and someone  who works at a large PD and has Law Enforcement Supervisory experience.

Guest Mustang6235
Posted

I was one that had to swallow the pill of having the board chose a vacancy over me. It was tough. But once I regrouped and reached out for help, I realized my package was awful. Literally, I wouldn’t have picked me either. 

 

I fixed that that the next year and selected as a 1of 1. 

 

So don’t give up. 

Posted

I heard that if your CCA doesn't show your record is being reviewed by whatever board you applied for, all the way until that board adjourns, that you didn't make it.  Does anybody know that to be true or is that a myth?

Posted
1 minute ago, YNC(SS)to6410 said:

#FAKE NEWS. 

figured that.

Posted

Hey everyone. I am also a Reservist and my package disappeared from my BOL back in December. It was there as an "A" but then it disappeared. Am I still good? I would hate to see that I wasn't selected because my package fell through the cracks.

Guest Sbreakall
Posted
11 minutes ago, Mustang6235 said:

I was one that had to swallow the pill of having the board chose a vacancy over me. It was tough. But once I regrouped and reached out for help, I realized my package was awful. Literally, I wouldn’t have picked me either. 

 

I fixed that that the next year and selected as a 1of 1. 

 

So don’t give up. 

I had an active duty O5 649X tell my CO I had no business applying after looking at my packet (minus civilian stuff), and a W5 649X tell me that I was a great candidate with a strong package. So I have no expectations at all. Haha

Guest Sbreakall
Posted
1 minute ago, JSB said:

Hey everyone. I am also a Reservist and my package disappeared from my BOL back in December. It was there as an "A" but then it disappeared. Am I still good? I would hate to see that I wasn't selected because my package fell through the cracks.

My packet was never in BOL, unless it appeared in December cause I never looked during that month. I was assured by PERS that this is normal for reservists. 

Guest McMustang6330
Posted
16 minutes ago, Sbreakall said:

It's just so different on the reserve side because the precepts mention civilian experience counting, but no guideline on what and how that experience counts. For example, 649X says that civilian law enforcement experience can be used to supplement navy experience, particularly at the sergeant level. There's no way for the board to know the difference between someone who works as a sergeant at a small PD and someone  who works at a large PD and has Law Enforcement Supervisory experience.

Admittedly, im relatively ignorant to the reserve side of things.  Surely, there is a way to break out your civilian experience and if you are leading/working in a large PD (in this example), you can highlight that somewhere.  Either in block 28, your writeup, or your CO's endorsement.  I have been wrong before though, so it wouldn't surprise me if its difficult to accomplish that.

Guest Mustang6235
Posted

The 6495 billet is tough for a non-MA. Trust me, I was a MM reservist and a civilian state trooper. That was one reason I didn’t select in 2015, I tried to make myself sound good for two things vice great for one. 

You have some good competition for the 626 spot. I think the quota was two this year. 

Guest OSC_FISH!
Posted

So is this another L today or nah? Asking for a friend... :)

Guest Sbreakall
Posted
Just now, Mustang6235 said:

The 6495 billet is tough for a non-MA. Trust me, I was a MM reservist and a civilian state trooper. That was one reason I didn’t select in 2015, I tried to make myself sound good for two things vice great for one. 

You have some good competition for the 626 spot. I think the quota was two this year. 

Yes, the quota was 2 this year. In the 4 previous years it was 1, and it was never filled.

 

If you dont mind me asking, what was your relative LE experience when you applied? I have been LE for 12 years; worked patrol, gangs, investigations, homicide, and now patrol sergeant. I was FP/AT Training Team on the navy side for my entire career, but secondary as my rate is GM and i was primarily an armorer on active duty. 

Guest Mustang6235
Posted
2 minutes ago, Sbreakall said:

Yes, the quota was 2 this year. In the 4 previous years it was 1, and it was never filled.

 

If you dont mind me asking, what was your relative LE experience when you applied? I have been LE for 12 years; worked patrol, gangs, investigations, homicide, and now patrol sergeant. I was FP/AT Training Team on the navy side for my entire career, but secondary as my rate is GM and i was primarily an armorer on active duty. 

7 years law enforcement when I tried that route. Being a trooper, it’s traffic/dwi/crash investigation centered. 

Guest Mustang6235
Posted

The MAs are big on pushing their people to applying LDO, and many of those are also civilian LEOs/supervisors. 

So they’re able to build an impressive Navy/civilian resume. 

 

Guest osiris0107
Posted

About to go to 😴. Hopefully I wake up to good news, but it seems like it’s another day of waiting.

Guest Rwar007
Posted

Sbreakall

Im not sure how the CIV LE works, I have combo of Navy MA and Federal gov 0083 LE experience totaling 15 years. Made LT (civ) in June of 17 and I honestly don’t know what else I can do at this point. Last year I spoke to a select and they didn’t even have a LE background outside of the Navy.......maybe they throw darts at a listing of applicant names.

B8282879-A2E0-4AFE-A8F0-F69C30CD47FA.jpeg

Guest McMustang6330
Posted

Unlike the results, im out for today!

Posted

Been following the forum for awhile, just received the confirmation email today for some reason. I’ve been feeling everyone’s pain though as I have been hitting F5 constantly hoping for the best. I’m a 628x applying for the first time. I feel like I had a strong package, I’m just hoping for the best. Good luck to everyone!

Posted
1 hour ago, Sbreakall said:

My packet was never in BOL, unless it appeared in December cause I never looked during that month. I was assured by PERS that this is normal for reservists. 

Great.

Thanks for the reply. Can't wait to see the results.

Guest OSC_FISH!
Posted
28 minutes ago, McMustang6330 said:

Unlike the results, im out for today!

I second that motion.... See y’all tomorrow!

Guest AMCSTack
Posted

I just got a text from a reputable person that tomorrow is the day!  I hope it’s accurate, I’m not good at waiting lol.  But knowing my luck they are messing with me cause I’m on leave.  Hopefully 5th times the charm :) 

Guest LDO_Hopeful88
Posted
1 hour ago, Sbreakall said:

It's just so different on the reserve side because the precepts mention civilian experience counting, but no guideline on what and how that experience counts. For example, 649X says that civilian law enforcement experience can be used to supplement navy experience, particularly at the sergeant level. There's no way for the board to know the difference between someone who works as a sergeant at a small PD and someone  who works at a large PD and has Law Enforcement Supervisory experience.

Yeah I applied for 649X as well and this is one of my big concerns for the opposite reason. I do not work in civilian law enforcement. I think I have a pretty solid application for Navy, but I'm afraid because I do not work in LE everyday it will hurt me. My 2 friends who have been selected are both civilian LE.

Posted

Am I the only Sub guy on here? Been through the whole thread and it seems like it. Maybe that works in my favor!

Guest STSC-CWO
Posted
4 minutes ago, SubETC said:

Am I the only Sub guy on here? Been through the whole thread and it seems like it. Maybe that works in my favor!

I’m an STSC, although I applied for the new 728X. 

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...
Forum Home
www.NavyAdvancement.com
Boots | Navy Patches
Serving enlisted, veterans, spouses & family