Looking for opinions on how big of a detractor a PFA failure 3 years ago could be. No excuses.. had a lot of crap going on outside of work and packed on a few extra pounds when my focus shifted other places. I've lost the weight, passed all before and all since then. I had JSOY at an FDNF squadron in 2015, I was SOY of an FRS this year #1 of 68. I feel like my evals are spot on regarding leadership for my juniors. I attached the most recent eval. I have had people say that it (PFA fail) won't be the reason I don't make it, and others have told me I absolutely will not make Chief with a fail on my record within the past 5 years. Thoughts? I think we're all at the point that we are overthinking everything now. First time selection board eligible and hoping I don't have to go through this feeling for many years to come LOL